This excerpt is from Second Opinion, a weekly analysis of health and medical science news sent to subscribers on Saturday mornings. To subscribe, click here.
If you find it hard to resist the cupcakes a colleague has brought to work, or if you’re struggling to concentrate on studying instead of scrolling through social media, psychologists suggest that the issue may extend beyond just lacking willpower.
An increasing amount of research indicates that individuals who demonstrate strong self-control typically achieve their success by steering clear of temptations. They modify their environments, establish social connections, and develop routines rather than constantly battling to resist.
Willpower refers to the exertion people use to overcome immediate temptations while aiming for long-term objectives. Self-control encompasses a wider range of behaviors: it can involve planning, habit formation, and structuring the environment to minimize reliance on willpower in the first place.
Instead of focusing on improving resistance to temptation, some researchers propose that the focus should be on encountering such temptations less frequently.
Michael Inzlicht, a psychology professor at the University of Toronto specializing in self-control, has observed that individuals who consciously use willpower succeed roughly half the time. In contrast, when they do not consciously exert that effort, their success rate remains around one-third.
The goal of resisting temptation may be misguided
Individuals who enjoy longer lifespans, save more money, and report stronger relationships often score high in conscientiousness, a personality trait linked to planning, perseverance, and organization.
However, Inzlicht argues that their goals may align more closely with their passions or identities. For instance, someone who enjoys sports might not view physical activity as a constant exercise in self-denial.
“They are more likely to be intrinsically motivated towards the goals they set for themselves, unlike non-conscientious individuals who often think, ‘I should do this,'” Inzlicht noted.
When he inquires about the motivations of people in the latter group, they often respond, “‘Because my doctor recommends it, or my spouse believes it’s beneficial for me, or I want to make my parents happy.'”
Inzlicht stated that if individuals can avoid temptations from the outset, they won’t need to depend as heavily on self-control.
He theorizes that the solution lies not solely in willpower, which can be unreliable, but in fostering a desire for behaviors deemed advantageous—ranging from eating healthy foods like broccoli and apples to engaging in activities like dancing or playing pickleball. However, he admits that testing this theory poses challenges.
This makes replication vital, according to Inzlicht, as findings gain credibility when they can be reproduced by independent researchers.
Concerns regarding replication have also muddled the widely held interpretation of the renowned marshmallow test, where children were asked to wait for a larger reward rather than taking a smaller one immediately.

Ongoing studies using a version of the marshmallow test continue to explore our capacity to delay gratification. (Charles Dharapak/The Associated Press)
Initial studies indicated that children who could delay gratification tended to have better life outcomes. However, subsequent research revealed that these correlations weakened significantly when researchers considered factors such as socioeconomic status and the child’s home environment, Inzlicht explained.
The role of environment in self-control
Zoë Francis, who studied goal pursuit while earning her PhD under Inzlicht, has examined how adults’ beliefs and expectations influence their self-control experiences.
Altering one’s environment can facilitate desired behaviors. For example, students may create study groups, while individuals facing stress might seek practical support from friends or family.
Francis cited online shopping as a case in point.

Utilizing tools like ad blockers can aid in resisting the lure of online shopping carts. (David Abrahams/CBC)
“Every time you decide not to purchase something, it’s a new decision,” Francis, a psychology professor at the University of the Fraser Valley in Abbotsford, B.C., remarked.
“However, by employing an ad blocker, unsubscribing from promotional emails, and avoiding influencers showcasing products, you effectively change your environment.”
Not everyone possesses the same capacity to manage their surroundings or utilize social support. Nevertheless, this principle is often applied in smoking cessation programs, where individuals are advised to identify and steer clear of triggers.
J. Bruce Morton, a psychology professor at Western University, conducts a version of the marshmallow test with participants ranging from toddlers to young adults. His research delves into how early experiences impact individuals’ ability to focus on relevant information and defer immediate rewards.
Morton remarked that he would not present avoidance and willpower as mutually exclusive options.
“Withdrawal symptoms can arise from anything that signals the body to expect nicotine,” Morton explained, noting that the sight and smell of smoke serve as powerful triggers. However, “steering clear of those triggers is an effective tactic to prevent relapse.”
Facilitating better choices
When students express a desire for improved grades, Inzlicht advises them to make their goals specific: determine how much they will study, where they will study, the time they will begin, and when to schedule it in their calendars.
-
AI slop videos aimed at babies are ‘garbage,’ says pediatrician
-
Cartoon villains with foreign accents drive language bias, Canadian study finds
For those looking to increase their exercise, Francis suggests making decisions in advance, like prepaying for a series of classes instead of deliberating whether to go to the gym at the end of the workday.
“A crucial aspect of a healthy and successful lifestyle is often that it transitions into a habit,” Francis stated. “When a goal is small and achievable, it becomes easier, allowing for gradual progression.”


